Food & Drink · Downtown St. Pete
Rewind St. Pete, a 1990s and 2000s bar, opens in the former Who's On First space
Tampa Bay Certified staff
Edited by Jack Croy · · 2 min read
Downtown St. Pete · November 13, 2026
Rewind St. Pete, a bar and restaurant themed around the 1990s and 2000s, opened Aug. 1 at 119 First Ave. N. in downtown St. Petersburg, in the space that housed the Who's On First? sports bar. The bar held its grand opening that day, according to the St. Pete Catalyst, and its website lists hours for each day of the week.
The owners
Partners Tony Graziano, John Huffington, Mike Jennings and Benny Hatfield own the bar, the Catalyst reported. Graziano and Huffington are based in Baltimore, and Jennings co-owned Who's On First?. The group took over that business in June, closed the bar after the Fourth of July and began the conversion, and began planning the project about four to five months before the opening.
Huffington told the Catalyst that the location suits the group because it is next to other bars Jennings owns, Dublin Drop and There Goes the Neighborhood, and that Rewind's kitchen supplies food to both of them.
Design and music
The Catalyst described the space as about 2,500 square feet. Its artwork, painted by Baltimore muralist Danny "D Lord" Lorden and his team, draws on television shows, movies, video games and commercials. The paper listed references to Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, Sonic the Hedgehog, Hey Arnold!, Rugrats, CatDog and the McDonald's Hamburglar. Lorden is art director of the Graffiti Mansion in Las Vegas, the Catalyst reported.
The bar plays 1990s and 2000s music, and Graziano curated part of the playlist. The carpet is inspired by roller rinks, and Huffington described the menu as Blockbuster-themed. Graziano said the goal was to take customers back to their childhood bedrooms.
Menu and hours
Keep reading
Finish this story
Drop your email to read the rest. You will also get the Tampa Bay Certified Thursday digest, with new openings, events, and the spots worth knowing. Unsubscribe in one tap, any time.
Keep reading
01 / 04
More from Tampa Bay
Food & Drink · Downtown St. Pete
Nov 16
Next Level Brands to Open Drift Bar at Sundial Courtyard in Downtown St. Pete
Next Level Brands will open Drift Bar, a cocktail bar, at the Sundial courtyard in downtown St. Pete.

Openings · Downtown St. Pete
KOJO and Tiki Bar Bar Hana Are Taking the Rooftop at St. Pete's Central Park

Run a business like Rewind St. Pete?
Get the same treatment.
260.8k people follow the publication. A feature is an editorial carousel on the feed, a permanent article on the publication, and story coverage on publish day. Features are paid. Send an inquiry for the price.
