Grey Matter Distillery, at 1221 Mayport Road in Atlantic Beach, placed third among craft vodka distilleries in USA TODAY 10Best's 2026 Readers' Choice Awards, results the site dated Oct. 21. The distillery, which describes its home as Mayport, makes Carve Craft Vodka.
How the ranking worked
The category was Best Craft Vodka. According to 10Best, a panel of experts nominated their top vodka picks and readers then voted for their favorites. Action News Jax reported on Sept. 17 that each category began with 20 nominees chosen by the panel, that readers could vote once a day until noon on Monday, Oct. 12, and that the 10 winners would be announced Oct. 21.
The published list names 10 distilleries. Sugarlands Distilling Company of Gatlinburg, Tennessee, took first place, followed by Smugglers' Notch Distillery of Jeffersonville, Vermont. Grey Matter came third, ahead of Red River Brewing Company & Distillery of Red River, New Mexico, and Central Standard Craft Distillery of Milwaukee. Action News Jax listed Grey Matter among four Northeast Florida distilleries nominated across the 10Best spirits categories.
What 10Best says about the distillery
10Best says Grey Matter started in 2014 in the basement of co-founder Paul Grey, part chemistry set and part homage to the television series "Breaking Bad." The site calls Carve Craft Vodka the distillery's flagship and says it is made from 100% corn, distilled seven times and filtered through activated coconut carbon. The write-up adds that visitors to the Atlantic Beach tasting room will find the vodka in drinks ranging from boozy popsicles to frozen concoctions.
The distillery's own website describes it as Jacksonville's first craft distillery and says it is locally and family owned. It says the business was founded in 2014 and opened to the public in 2021 in Mayport, when it introduced its cocktail lounge. The website says owner Paul Grey built the bar by hand and that the founders, staff and friends built the rest of the space themselves.
Besides Carve, the distillery says it distills and bottles Live Oak Whiskey, Mayport Moonshine and Ribault Rum on site.




